CRAFT Hardwood Guides
Understanding Wood Floor Finishes:
Oil vs Lacquer Explained
Once you've chosen your floor, there's one more decision that will shape how it looks, feels, and behaves for the next twenty or thirty years.
Written by Wojciech, founder of CRAFT Hardwood | Updated March 2026 | 12 min read
Once the floor is chosen and the installation planned, there's one more decision worth taking seriously: the finish.
It's a decision that affects more than appearance. The finish determines how your floor ages, how you maintain it, how it feels underfoot, and how it responds to the daily life of your household — for decades.
We apply both oil and lacquer finishes regularly across Lancashire and Greater Manchester, and we're asked regularly which is better. The honest answer is that neither is universally superior. They're different in ways that matter, and understanding those differences before you decide is worth the time.
After finishing hundreds of floors since 2012, we've learned that the right choice depends on your lifestyle, your aesthetic preferences, and how hands-on you want to be with maintenance. This guide explains both options honestly — including what we use on our own floors at home.
The Two Finishes — What They Actually Are
Oil Finish
Oil penetrates into the wood fibres, protecting the timber from within rather than coating it from above. It doesn't create a surface film — it enhances the wood's natural characteristics while providing protection against moisture and wear.
The oils we use are modern hardwax oils — a combination of natural oils and hard waxes that produce a durable, low-sheen finish. The brands we work with regularly are Osmo, Treatex, and Bona.
Lacquer Finish
Lacquer creates a protective film on the surface of the wood. It sits on top of the timber, forming a clear, hard-wearing barrier between the wood and daily life.
Modern water-based lacquers have largely replaced older solvent-based varnishes — they're more durable, don't yellow over time, and have none of the strong odours associated with older products. The products we use are Bona Traffic and Bona Mega.
How They Look
This is often the deciding factor — and it's worth understanding the difference before you see samples, not after.
An oiled floor looks and feels like natural wood. The finish is low-sheen — typically 10–30% sheen level — and enhances the grain and character of the oak rather than sitting over it. Run your hand across an oiled floor and you feel the wood texture. It looks like timber that's been cared for, not sealed away behind a coating. The oil tends to slightly warm the wood tone, bringing out the golden hues in oak.
A lacquered floor has a smoother, more uniform surface. The wood grain is visible but you're touching the lacquer rather than the timber. Modern lacquers are available across a wide range of sheens — from dead matte at 10% through to high gloss at 90% — which gives considerably more control over the finished appearance than oil.
In our experience, clients choosing traditional herringbone in period properties most often prefer oil for its natural, authentic appearance. Clients choosing contemporary installations, or those who prioritise low maintenance, more often prefer lacquer. But there are no rules — we've installed lacquer in Victorian hallways and oil in contemporary new builds, and both looked exactly right.
Durability and How They Wear
Both finishes are durable when correctly applied. The difference isn't in how long they last — it's in how they wear.
Oil wears gradually and gracefully. Scratches blend into the matte finish rather than showing as distinct lines. High-traffic areas slowly look drier and lighter over time — which is your cue to re-oil rather than a sign of damage. The floor develops patina. It ages in the way good natural materials age — with character rather than deterioration.
Lacquer maintains a consistent appearance for years, then shows wear more suddenly when the surface film begins to break down. Scratches appear as distinct lines rather than blending in. When a lacquered floor eventually shows wear, it tends to dull in high-traffic areas or develop surface marks that require professional refinishing to address.
For traffic levels specifically:
-
Light traffic — bedroom, study: both finishes are excellent.
-
Medium traffic — living room, dining room: both finishes are excellent.
-
High traffic — hallway, kitchen: lacquer is more practical for long-term durability.
-
Very high traffic — commercial: lacquer is the right choice.
One important distinction on repairability: oiled floors can be spot-repaired. A damaged area can be cleaned, lightly sanded, and re-oiled without touching the rest of the floor. Lacquered floors cannot be invisibly spot-repaired — damaged areas require full refinishing of the affected room. This difference matters more than most people realise when something goes wrong.
Maintenance — What Each Finish Actually Requires
This is where the practical difference between the two finishes is most significant for daily life.
Oiled Floors
Day-to-day cleaning is simple — sweep or vacuum regularly, damp mop with water or a specialist wood floor cleaner, wipe spills promptly. The same as any wood floor.
Every two to three years, the floor needs a maintenance coat of oil. High-traffic areas may need attention more frequently; low-traffic areas can go three years or more between coats. The process is straightforward — clean the floor thoroughly, apply a thin coat of hardwax oil, buff the excess after twenty to thirty minutes, and the floor is ready to walk on after eight to twelve hours. Professional maintenance coating costs £8–15/m². Confident homeowners can do this themselves.
For the long term, a full sand and re-oil is typically needed every fifteen to twenty-five years — or longer with good maintenance.
Lacquered Floors
Day-to-day cleaning is identical — sweep, vacuum, damp mop, wipe spills. No periodic re-coating is needed. An annual or bi-annual application of floor refresher polish is optional rather than necessary.
When lacquer eventually shows wear — typically after ten to fifteen years, sooner in very high-traffic areas like stairs and doorways — the floor needs a full professional sand and refinish. This cannot be done as a DIY project.
The practical difference in one sentence: oiled floors need more frequent but less intensive attention; lacquered floors need virtually nothing for a decade, then require professional intervention when they eventually wear.
The Cost Over Time
Initial application costs are fairly similar, with lacquer being slightly more expensive due to multiple coats and longer application time.
Oil finish initial application: £8–12/m² as part of installation.
Lacquer finish initial application: £13–20/m² as part of installation.
Over twenty years, the picture looks different.
Oil finish — twenty year cost example:
Initial application £10/m², plus re-oiling every two years — nine applications at £10–15/m² each — gives a total twenty-year cost of approximately £100–145/m².
Lacquer finish — twenty year cost example:
Initial application £15/m², plus full sand and refinish at year ten to twelve at £40–50/m², gives a total twenty-year cost of approximately £55–70/m².
However — and this is important — the oil calculation assumes professional maintenance throughout. Many homeowners apply oil maintenance coats themselves, bringing the DIY material cost to £3–8/m² per application rather than £10–15/m². If you're comfortable with occasional DIY maintenance, oil can be considerably more economical over the long term. If you prefer hands-off maintenance and professional-only intervention, lacquer's lower frequency is genuinely appealing.
Which Suits Your Lifestyle
Oil tends to suit people who appreciate natural materials and are comfortable with periodic maintenance. It's particularly right for period properties — more historically appropriate for Victorian and Edwardian homes, and it produces the authentic, tactile floor that these buildings were designed to have. It's also well suited to families where scratches and marks are inevitable — they blend into the finish rather than showing as distinct damage, and small areas can be touched up without refinishing the whole floor.
Lacquer tends to suit people who want the lowest possible maintenance commitment. Set it down, clean it regularly, and it looks after itself for a decade. It's the right choice for rental properties where tenants won't maintain the floor, for very high-traffic areas, and for contemporary interiors where a consistent, polished appearance is the goal.
Neither is the wrong choice for a kitchen — we install both in kitchens regularly and both handle normal spills without issue. Neither is suitable for genuinely wet areas like bathrooms.
How They Feel Underfoot
An oiled floor feels warm, slightly textured, and natural. You're walking on wood that's been nourished rather than sealed. Many people describe it as feeling more alive. In winter it doesn't feel as cold as lacquer.
A lacquered floor feels smoother and slightly cooler underfoot. You're walking on a sealed surface that's protecting the wood beneath. Some people prefer this polished, refined feel — particularly noticeable in bare feet.
Neither is better. It's genuinely personal preference, and we always recommend experiencing both in person before deciding.
How They Age
Oiled floors develop patina over the years — a subtle deepening and warming of colour as the wood continues to breathe and respond to its environment. High-traffic areas develop slightly more character than low-traffic areas, creating gentle variation across the floor. This ageing is considered desirable by most people who choose oil. The floor tells the story of your home.
Lacquered floors maintain their original appearance very consistently for a decade or more. The sealed surface protects the wood from UV exposure and environmental changes, so colour remains more stable. When the lacquer eventually shows wear, it tends to dull in high-traffic areas rather than developing patina — at which point refinishing restores it to its original appearance.
Moisture and Spills
Both finishes handle normal household spills well. Wipe up promptly and neither will be damaged by a spilled glass of wine or an overflowing dog bowl.
The difference matters in more extreme situations. Oil's penetrating nature means moisture cannot easily get between the finish and the wood — brief exposure to significant water, such as a minor leak, is tolerated better than lacquer. With lacquer, if water gets under the surface film through a scratch or worn area, it can cause the film to lift. The key with lacquer is maintaining an intact surface — which is why prompt attention to scratches matters more with lacquer than with oil.
Neither finish is appropriate for bathrooms. Both are entirely suitable for kitchens.
A Note on Environmental Considerations
Modern hardwax oils are often based on natural, renewable plant oils with low VOC emissions. They're breathable — the wood continues to regulate moisture naturally — and produce no off-gassing after curing. The odour during application is natural rather than chemical, though good ventilation is still needed.
Modern water-based lacquers are a significant improvement on the old solvent-based varnishes — low VOC, minimal odour, no yellowing. They create a vapour barrier rather than allowing the wood to breathe, but in a normally ventilated modern home this isn't a practical issue.
Both are safe, low-VOC products when properly applied. The era of strong-smelling, yellowing varnishes is long past.
Common Misconceptions Worth Addressing
"Oil isn't as durable as lacquer."
Modern hardwax oils are extremely durable. They wear differently from lacquer — gradually rather than maintaining then suddenly deteriorating — but durability is not the weakness.
"Lacquer looks plastic and unnatural."
This came from old gloss varnishes. Modern matte and satin lacquers look very natural and nothing like the shiny coatings of thirty years ago.
"Oil requires constant maintenance."
Re-oiling every two to three years is not onerous, particularly if you do it yourself. It's far less disruptive than a full sand and refinish.
"You can't use oil in kitchens."
We install oiled floors in kitchens regularly. Oil handles moisture well and is entirely suitable.
"Lacquer will peel and flake."
Only if poorly applied or if water gets beneath the surface film. Quality water-based lacquer, properly applied, doesn't peel.
What We Use on Our Own Floors
Our team is genuinely split on this — which we think is the most honest possible recommendation.
Wojciech has oiled herringbone at home. He loves the natural look and the way the floor has developed over the years, and re-oiling every couple of years doesn't feel like a burden.
Michael, who installs alongside Wojciech, has matte lacquer over his herringbone. With young children, the lower maintenance commitment suits his household better.
Both are entirely happy with their choices — because each chose the finish that was right for their specific situation. That's exactly the conversation we have with every client before a finish is decided.
Making the Decision
If you're still weighing it up, these are the questions worth asking yourself:
-
Do you love natural, matte aesthetics and want a floor that develops character over time? → Oil
-
Do you want minimal maintenance and a consistent appearance for a decade? → Lacquer
-
Are you renovating a period property and want historical authenticity? → Oil
-
Do you have very high traffic or a rental property? → Lacquer
-
Are you comfortable with occasional DIY maintenance? → Oil will likely cost less over time.
-
Do you prefer professional-only intervention every ten to fifteen years? → Lacquer suits that preference.
Both finishes will protect your floor for decades. Neither is the wrong choice. The question is which characteristics align better with how you live.
Our Process
When we install your floor, we bring samples of both finishes on actual oak in your chosen colour — not catalogue photographs, but physical samples you can see in your own light and feel underfoot. We'll discuss your household, your maintenance preferences, and your aesthetic instincts before making any recommendation. And we'll be honest if we think one finish is clearly more suited to your specific situation than the other.
Choosing a finish for your floor?
We're happy to visit, bring samples, and talk through which option suits your property, your lifestyle, and your plans for the floor. There's no obligation — sometimes the most useful thing we do on a site visit is help someone make a confident decision rather than leaving with a quote.
We offer free site visits across Lancashire, Greater Manchester, Merseyside, and Cheshire.
Call: 07856 308 208 Email: contact@crafthardwood.co.uk
We serve Chorley, Lancashire, Greater Manchester, Liverpool, Chester, and throughout the North West.